If there’s one thing that makes Christmas dinner unforgettable (besides the questionable family karaoke session), it’s the dessert table.
And honestly, nothing feels quite as festive—or as comforting—as a homemade pie.
PIN FOR LATER 📌
From flaky crusts to spiced fillings that taste like nostalgia, Christmas pies are the kind of cozy, crowd-pleasing treat that turns a holiday meal into a full-on memory.
I’ve pulled together 21 Christmas pie recipes that range from timeless classics (think pecan and pumpkin) to creative twists worthy of a Hallmark movie spread.
Whether you’re baking for family, hosting friends, or just craving something sweet by the fire with a Netflix marathon, these pies are guaranteed to bring the holiday magic.
1. Peppermint Chocolate Pie Recipe
CREDIT: GRANDBABY CAKES
Cool, minty, and rich—peppermint chocolate pie is one of those desserts I can never resist around the holidays. It’s fresh, festive, and oh-so-decadent.
EVERYONE’S CLICKING ON:
2. Pumpkin Pie
CREDIT: TASTES BETTER FROM SCRATCH
Pumpkin pie is a Christmas classic for a reason. Smooth, spiced, and topped with a dollop of cream—this is the kind of pie that makes me want to cozy up with a blanket by the fire.
3. S’mores Pie
CREDIT: THE GIRL WHO ATE EVERYTHING
Think summer campfire, but make it holiday-ready. This gooey S’mores pie with chocolate, marshmallows, and graham cracker goodness is nostalgic and irresistible.
4. Gingerbread Pie
CREDIT: AN EDIBLE MOSAIC
Gingerbread and Biscoff together? Yes, please. This pie is spiced, creamy, and topped with plenty of that cookie crunch—it’s the ultimate Christmas comfort dessert.
5. White Chocolate Cranberry Tart
CREDIT: DELIGHT FUEL
This stunning tart feels like it came straight out of a bakery window. Creamy white chocolate filling, tart cranberries, and a festive garnish—it’s elegant and delicious.
6. No-Bake Nutella Pie with Hazelnut Praline
CREDIT: COOKING ON THE WEEKENDS
I mean… Nutella + pie? Say less. This creamy no-bake Nutella pie topped with crunchy hazelnut praline is an instant crowd-pleaser (and a total no-stress option for busy holiday hosting).
7. Traditional Mince Pies
CREDIT: DARING GOURMET
You really can’t have Christmas without a tray of mince pies. Sweet, spiced fruit tucked inside buttery pastry and dusted with sugar—they’re classic, cozy, and honestly one of my favorite holiday traditions.
8. Low Sugar Dark Chocolate Chunk Pecan Pie
CREDIT: RACHAEL HARTLEY
Pecan pie is already a holiday staple, but add melty chocolate chunks? Game over. I didn’t think it could get better—then I tried this.
9. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie
CREDIT: THE CREATIVE BITE
This one is a flavor explosion—bright, tart cranberries meet silky smooth orange custard. It’s refreshing, festive, and totally worthy of a spot on your Christmas dessert table.
10. No-Bake Gingerbread Pie
CREDIT: CHOCOLATE MOOSEY
This no-bake gingerbread pie is basically Christmas in dessert form. Spiced, creamy, and topped with fluffy whipped cream—it’s like skipping straight to the best part of the holidays.
11. Coconut Macaroon Pie
CREDIT: SPICY SOUTHERN KITCHEN
Light, sweet, and full of coconut flavor, this pie is like a tropical Christmas dream. I love how the chewy coconut topping pairs with the flaky crust.
12. Maple Sweet Potato Pie
CREDIT: EVERYDAY PIE
Silky smooth with a hint of maple sweetness, this one feels like pumpkin pie’s more sophisticated cousin. I love how it tastes both classic and unexpected.
13. Cranberry Crumb Pie
CREDIT: BAKING SENSE
Packed with tart berries and a buttery crumb topping, it’s the kind of pie that pairs perfectly with a mug of mulled wine.
14. Christmas Tree Hand Pies
CREDIT: THE COUNTRY COOK
Cute, portable, and festive—these little hand pies are the definition of holiday cheer. I’d wrap them in parchment and give them as edible gifts.
15. Fudge Brownie Pie
CREDIT: SALLY’S BAKING ADDICTION
A fudgy brownie baked into a pie crust? Say less. This is the ultimate “bring it to the party and wow everyone” dessert.
16. Apple Cranberry Crumble Pie
CREDIT: TUTTI DOLCE
Sweet, tart, and topped with the most irresistible oat crumble. This is the pie I’d reach for when I want cozy comfort.
17. No-Bake Mint Chocolate Chip Pie
CREDIT: DINNERS, DISHES AND DESSERTS
It’s giving after-dinner mint but in pie form—creamy, refreshing, and just the right amount of indulgent.
18. Delicious Bourbon & Mixed Berries Pie
CREDIT: THE GRUMPY OLIVE
A classic with a festive twist—this cranberry and Bourbon filling looks as good as it tastes. Honestly, I’d bake it just for that picture-perfect lattice top.
19. Snickerdoodle Pie Recipe
CREDIT: SOMETHING SWANKY
Basically two desserts in one, and I’m not mad about it. Warm, spiced, and drizzled with icing—it screams Christmas morning.
20. Plum Pie
CREDIT: SAVING ROOM FOR DESSERT
Juicy, jewel-toned plums tucked into a golden lattice crust—this pie feels both rustic and festive. I love it with a dusting of sugar on top for a little sparkle.
21. Chocolate Raspberry Pie
CREDIT: FAT DAD FOODIE
This one’s rich, silky, and a little flirty with the raspberry topping. I’d 100% save room for a slice (or two).